Showing posts with label kindle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label kindle. Show all posts

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Highlight This

I shuffle out of my classroom at 4:00 without any of daybreak’s energy and enthusiasm.  My mind is heavy with the unfinished paperwork piled on my desk and my heart is holding onto the tiny teaching victories I collected throughout the day.  “All Things Considered” is a salve as I drive home on autopilot, forgetting to stop at the post office and drug store.  Today I am delighted and actually laugh outloud as Andrei Codrescu rants about the new ebook “improvement” that Amazon has wrought on their customers.
The horrendous idea began as a semi-harmless list of the book passages that were most highlighted by Kindle readers … Amazon tracked what readers were marking and, by comparing all customers data they could see what was most popular.  I agree with Rebekah Denn that the practice is a little creepy and it gives me that big brother feeling, like you’re not really alone even though you’re in your flannel pjs in bed.  A book is supposed to be a one way data stream:  the author writes it, you read it and then you decide what to do with the new information.  Maybe you want to talk about,  write about it, read about it or ponder it.  But the Kindle is a door to and from the Internet.  Now Amazon can reach through the Internet and keep track of what you find interesting for its “popular highlights” feature (I suppose one does have the choice of highlighting in the first place).

But then they went too far ...Andrei explains that his brand new, hot off the wires, e-book arrived on his Kindle WITH highlighting - yuk!  At first he thought it was a mistake, but then he discovered that the underlining in his book was pointing out the ‘popular highlights’.   He was appropriately disgusted, who cares what hundred of “morons” (his words not mine) found interesting in a book, reading is not a public forum, it a private, sacred experience between the text and the reader (at least it used to be).  The idea of a pre-hightlighted book is like ABC gum (already been chewed), hand me down socks or a pencil with the eraser chewed off - they have been violated..  
I thought back to my entry about marginalia.  What if the book came with Mark Twain’s highlights, or the author’s highlights?  That might be an  interesting addition to the book  but it doesn’t change the fact that when you buy a new book it is because you want to experience the thoughts and stories of the author on your own - not with the general public (that’s what Facebook is for).  The “value added” highlighting takes away from the personal experience of reading.  
There is also a privacy issue.  On the “Red Tape Chronicles”, Bob Sullivan notes, “It's possible Kindle users are unaware that they are contributing to the "popular highlights " feature, which launched quietly to some users who downloaded the latest version of Kindle software beginning last month. Popular Highlights is turned on by default.”  
Tracking the books we buy is one thing but keeping track of passage that we find inspiring, questionable, or thought provoking crosses the line from helpful to nosy.  Asking me to pay full price for a book that some bozo (my words) has already underlined is ludicrous - I’ll do my thinking on my own, thank you very much - and I won’t do it on a Kindle.
By the way, I found today’s most highlighted passage from Cutting for Stone by Abraham Verghese inspiring and added his book to my “to read” list - so I guess the marketing gurus at Amazon win again (not really because I’ll check the book out of the library).

“The key to your happiness is to own your slippers, own who you are, own how you look, own your family, own the talents you have, and own the ones you don’t. If you keep saying your slippers aren’t yours, then you’ll die searching, you’ll die bitter, always feeling you were promised more. Not only our actions, but also our omissions, become our destiny.”   

Monday, March 7, 2011

OverDrive

I love to read about companies succeeding in ‘the rust belt’.  Unfortunately it’s not an everyday (every month, year) occurrence.  More companies are packing up and leaving cities that were once manufacturing giants (Buffalo, Cleveland, Toledo and Detroit) than moving in.  But not OverDrive Inc.  
OverDrive is a growing company in a quickly expanding field that was founded, and remains, in Cleveland, Ohio.  OverDrive began with diskettes and CDs in the 1980s and adapted to meet the digital needs of schools, libraries and retailers. Now OverDrive distributes digital materials to libraries around the world.  They provide the interface and supply the licenses for libraries to offer downloadable ebooks, audiobooks and other digital content.  These virtual books can be downloaded onto computers, phones, ipods and book readers.  Overdrive currently provide services for 13,000 libraries, including my system in Niagara County and the New York Public Library (the websites look almost the same!).  Overdrive provides a “virtual library” environment that is customized to fit each library and handles the behind the scenes technology that makes it all work.
While I’m excited that OverDrive had a 200% increase in circulation last year, I’m a little worried about the libraries.  In USA Today, Jonathan Ellis reported that each ebook license costs significantly more than a printed book (which typically is heavily discounted for the library).  This year libraries are struggling to keep the lights on and the doors open - definitely not a good time to make major investments in new technology.  While book budgets can be redirected, you can’t get blood from a stone.  
And how about the different formats of e-readers, the Nook and Kindle are currently battling for market share and don’t support the same ebooks format (the Nook and many other e-readers use epub but the Kindle does not).  Are you old enough to remember the Beta vs. VHS battle?  I remember a video rental place we went to when I was a teenager that was divided in half to offer both types of tapes and I always worried that either way the market went they were destined to lose a lot of money.  They are certainly rolling the dice at Hennepin County Library in Minneapolis, MN.  Gail Mueller Schultz, who manages the libraries collection, reported that they went from spending $35,000 on e-books last year to $350,000 this year.  I know that will keep the patrons happy, I just hope it pays off for the library in the decades to come.