Showing posts with label additions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label additions. Show all posts

Saturday, August 13, 2011

Rockland Synergy


My favorite modern library incarnation is like a tootsie pop with history at the core and sugary convenience wrapped around the outside.  I relish it backwards, first exploring the history, reading each plaque, touching the wood and wrought iron, meditating in the reading room, gazing at the ceiling and examining all the portraits.  After satisfying my need for context and meaning I return to the present and head to the audio books on DVD.

Typically, the old libraries are stiff, dark, formal and imposing while the new libraries are the opposite, bright, light, airy and open.  The juxtaposition is complimentary, offering a taste of a the past with a heaping portion of the future on the side.  

The Rockland Library in Maine has balanced the arrangement gracefully.  The original Carnegie building remains in tact, complete with circulation desk, decorative iron dividers and Carnegie oil portrait.  But the back wall of the library is blown out to accommodate a new sunny addition.  The seam, where the two buildings meet is a glass structure that delicately balances on the original stone.  It allows you to stand back and see the back of the original library from inside the new library. 

The old library is divided between a stately, peaceful reading room and book stacks.  Peace and quiet prevail under Carnegie’s watchful eye.  The children’s room, in the addition, is as far away from the reading room as physically possible.  A perfect arrangement for families who want to read out loud, build block towers and work on puzzles together.  At the turn of the century, architects couldn’t have even imagined needing this space.  Children were not part of the library equation and when they were let out in public they not encouraged to be heard.  

Surprisingly there are only 18 Carnegie libraries in Maine.  Rockland’s was built in 1904 thanks to a $20,000 donation from Carnegie and the addition was added in 2001.  I am confident that the synergy they have accomplished will keep Carnegie smiling for another 100 years.  Who knows what we will build after that.

Saturday, July 30, 2011

Mutt and Madonna

From Architect Magazine
I'm not sure why I was so surprised by the old and new Cambridge Public Library buildings sitting side by side in the park in Cambridge since I had just left the BPL, but I was.  


At first it seemed that the cities had found parallel solutions for their expansion, but after reading Joann Goncher’s article in Architectural Record, I started to understand the differences.

In Boston the star is the McKim Building.  It is what people come to see and a symbol of what libraries stand for in our country.  It is an historic landmark in every sense of the word.  
The Johnson Building, opening in 1972, must have seemed modern at the time but now is very ho-hum.  My daughter described it as ‘meh’ and I agreed.  Although it’s a modern building, the open book stacks on the first floor seemed cluttered and messy - missing the cool, clean lines we expect in a modern building.  To 21st century eyes it’s an understandable necessity, not a architectural treasure.


In Cambridge the Richardson Romanesque library, built in 1888 by Van Brunt & Howe is in a 4 acre park, so there is the advantage of elbow room.  It is also a beautiful building but, obviously, doesn’t hold the same cultural significance as the McKim.  Cambridge knew they wanted a ‘town common’ type space that would serve everyone in their diverse community, they knew they didn’t want to overshadow the old library and they had about $69 million to play with.



In 2009 William Rawn Associates unveiled the resulting new library.  It is stunning in its own right and  only compliments its elderly neighbor.  The new library offers patrons state of the art, LEED certified facilities and an undisturbed view of the ever changing park scenery.  The buildings are so different that they are less like Mutt and Jeff than Mutt and Madonna, but they are both beautiful and representative of their genre and context.  There is no possible way for them to compete, so they don’t.  

Photo by Robert Benson

The new building looks as if it is made entirely of glass.  The front wall  was designed with two glass walls that have a three foot gap between them.  At the top of the wall dampers control the temperature and shades in between the walls prevent patrons from getting blinded by the sun’s glare.  The buildings are connected by a glass bridge and the new space quadruples the library’s square footage.


The original granite and sandstone building was renovated during the project and I love that they choose to put the new teen lounge in the old building.  In a behind-the-scenes space that was previously used for book stacks, the designers decided to keep the mechanical systems and brick walls exposed, which gives the laid back space an unexpected industrial vibe, completely unlike the traditional oak paneled reading room that was meant for patrons.  That space has also been renovated to its original glory and boasts a large wall mural that chronicle library/book history.  


Inside the new building the red walls and ceiling keep the environment fun and fresh for the 1,500 daily visitors.  CPL Director, Susan Flannery explained that on the first floor patrons were allowed to eat, drink and chat, just like in a trendy bookstore.  Architectural Record called the space an “appealing book emporium”.


Cambridge was rewarded with the 2010 Harleston Parker Medal for the “Single Most Beautiful Building” built in the Boston during the past 10 years.  The jury report writes that the library, “exhibits formal beauty as well as beauty of purpose, and the experience of the building as a place is not only beautiful for its form, its building science, its sustainable design, its materials, its program, but also for the vibrant activity and undisputable joy within.”

What else can I say?  Check out the slide show for yourself.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Growing Pains


Every old city library in our young country has had them, they’re painful and unpleasant but impossible to ignore... growing pains.  Of course it would be unrealistic to think that structures build a century (or more) ago could continue to meet the information needs of today’s population but choosing to raze a historic library is not, and should not, be an easy decision.  

When a library has more books in storage than on the shelf, decision time has arrived.  There are many factors to consider:  the condition of the building, the cost of renovation, the cost of new construction, the site, the importance of the building and the support of the community.   Some cities make a logical decision to demolish and start over, and some create stunning statements for their cities and patrons (see Seattle).  Other cities choose to preserve their history and build an addition onto the existing libraries, which can be architecturally challenging but, if done well, the best of both worlds.  In New York City they have added on to the original building and used book annexes to handle their phenomenal growth.

In 1910 the population of New York City was 4.7 million.  According to census, by the year 2010 it had ballooned to 8.3 million, a pretty major jump.  Now I know that not everyone loves or uses the library in NYC but I also know that each week 350,000 patrons do stop by one of the NYPL branches, and they all need a place to sit and read.  Well, not really, but they do need access to the 20 million books in the library’s collection (in 1911 the library only had a million items).

To accommodate the first wave of this explosion in the 1970s, the New York Public Library came up with some creative solutions, none of which included a new main library.  The NYPL is a monument in and of itself, and a National Historic Landmark - which establishes it as a place of historic significance and provides it with a certain amount of protection.  Instead of building up or out the library decided to go down.

NYPL is famous for the seven floors of stacks below the reading room which was the brainstorm of Dr. John Shaw Billings, the first library director, way back in 1900.  In order to get a book, patrons fill out a request slip and it is swooshed up them (this was pretty revolutionary in the early 1900s).  But as the collection grew there was a greater need for shelf space so the library made like a mole and tunneled 62 feet under Bryant Park, eventually digging out an additional 125,000 square feet and adding  84 miles of shelf space .  

Susan Anderson’s 1987 article in the NYT fills in some of the details. Before the expansion the books in the humanities and social sciences collection were split up and some were stored in the annex on 43rd Street and 11th Avenue.  The new space reunited the collection for the time but because the library acquires 150,000 new books a year, it would clearly not last forever.  The previous chairman of the library and Bryant Park, Andrew Haiskell, said that when the library grew too big for its britches again it would be “someone else’s problem” which turned out to be exactly what happened.  During the years of construction Bryant Park was closed for the 2 ½ years of construction work.  When the space was complete, about 6 feet of soil was added to the roof, a little grass was planted and the park was back in business.  

Sadly, the miles of stacks are closed to the public with he exception of a few special days.  And even though Ghostbuster wasn’t actually filmed there (they went to LA instead!), I can imagine the eerie feeling of being surrounded by miles of identical rows of books and no natural light,  enough to make anyone a little nervous...personally I rather sit up in the Rose Room, under billowing clouds, and wait for my book to be swooshed up to me.

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Lucky Crane

I’m not sure what I believe about the afterlife but I sure hope that Thomas Crane can look down from wherever he is and see what his son did.  In 1880, six years after Thomas’s death, his son, Albert Crane, sent a surprising letter to the Selectmen of Quincy, including Charles Francis Adams (John Adams grandson) stating that his family wanted to “erect a memorial” to their father.  
photo from waymarking.com
Even though Albert, one of Thomas’s eight children, had never lived in Quincy he wrote that his father had held onto “a strong feeling for the town of Quincy” where his family had lived for over a century.  Albert suggested that they build a memorial in the center of town called “Crane Memorial Hall” that would include a library.  It is possible that the soaring costs of the building eventually led to the elimination of sections of the building and the decision was made to make the memorial a library.
Thomas Crane left Quincy for New York City when he was 26 and made his fortune in building and real estate.  He eventually became the owner of his own stone yard and, after a NYC fire in 1835, watched his Quincy Granite become a hot commodity.  The granite trade grew and so did Crane’s wealth and prominence.  He helped build NY Custom House and the old Grand Central Station.  When Crane died in 1875 he had amassed a fortune.  Which is probably why Albert had $20,000 to spend on a library and an endowment AND he also had an architect in mind:  H.H. Richardson.  Richardson set to work to create one of his most successful buildings of his career (see yesterday’s post ‘Best Loved Buildings’).  The library opened to the residents of Quincy in 1882.
As Quincy grew the Crane family’s support matched it.  The family funded the first renovation in 1908, designed by William M. Aiken.   They pitched in again in the 1930s to fund a major addition by architects Paul and Carroll Coletti and the money even held out to provide the initial funding for the 2001 CBT addition!  I certainly hope the fortune made it through the recent financial disaster unscathed (and not just for the library’s sake).  
Thomas Crane never saw the library built in his name and I wonder what he would make of its greatness.  I think that he would be enormously proud of his legacy in Quincy.  It is an exquisite building, designed by a gifted architect and could never be recreated.  But the real beauty of a ‘library as memorial’ is the joy, learning and enlightenment that has been given to all the people that have walked through its great doors in the last 130 years and continue to do so everyday.  We should all be so lucky.
*I was so grateful to find the “The Crane Library” by L. Draper Hill, Jr. (published in 1962) as a PDF online.  It is so exciting to find authentic historical accounts from primary document that reveal the personal stories behind the creation of great institutions.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Best Loved

Photo from Crane Library Website

In 2007 the American Institute of Architects and Harris Interactive embarked on a public poll to determine the 150 best loved building in America as a way to celebrate their 150th Anniversary.  It is absolutely no surprise the The Thomas Crane Memorial Library in Quincy, MA was number 43.  Trinity Church ranks 25 which gives H.H. Richardson two building in the top 50.  It’s particularly interesting to look at the other winners, they are mostly grandiose structures, built on a monumental scale (Sears Tower, Washington Monument, St. Patrick’s Cathedral), the Crane Library is tucked away between them like a little brother tagging along with the big kids.  The only other library higher on the list is The Library of Congress!  I can’t believe it took me so long to discover this gem.  The more I learn, the less I know.
When the poll was conducted, the AIA asked people to choose buildings that symbolized  innovation and the spirit of their community (or country).  But they also were looking for structures that held a special place in people’s hearts and minds.  That is what strikes me with all of Richardson’s libraries - they are warm and inviting yet also convey security and stability with their beauty.  They are crafted from gorgeous organic materials in a simple but decorative way - Richardson’s talent is overwhelming.  In Quincy he had a little help from Frederick Law Olmsted (Central Park) who designed the grounds and the artist John Lafarge who contributed three stained glass windows.
Richardson’s genius is the problem for those who come in his wake, especially for those who are charged with expanding his masterpiece.  CBT  (Childs Bertman Tseckares Inc.) designed a $16 million addition to the library that doubled the existing space, created a soaring atrium and added essential circulation and reference areas.  But even CBT architect Richard Bertman admits that “ you can’t buy the kind of ornamentation and sculpture that grace both the original H.H. Richardson library building or the 1939 addition known as the Coletti building.”  The library has actually expanded not once but four times in the last 120 years - and with good reason;  it has the second largest collection in Massachusetts after the Boston Public Library.  CBT also took care of renovating and restoring the existing buildings - get a towel because you will drool over the pictures of the interior.  The old and new Crane Library compliment each other (like the ultimate Reese’s PB Cup) to offer the residents of Quincy a spacious, remarkable haven for learning, sharing and thinking.  They are prepared to move into the future without forgetting the past.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Woburn's Woes

Photo from the SciWoburn Website
It was a happy afternoon when I discovered that H.H. Richardson had designed not one but FOUR fantastic libraries around Boston in the 1880s.  After checking out the Ames Free Library in Easton I headed to Woburn, about 10 miles north of Boston on Route 93.  The library does not disappoint.  Seated on a spacious hill, the rugged red and cream limestone blocks create a imposing structure that is at once serious and welcoming.  The Woburn Library  is  grander in scale than it’s cousin in Easton but they are irrefutably related.  Woburn was actually Richardson’s first library of the series and he pulled out all the stops - rows of arched windows, a 78 ft. tower and an octagonal exhibition room with his signature arched entryway.  All elements these elements came to be know at Richardsonian Romanesque.
The town’s library legacy began way back in 1853 when Jonathon Bowers Winn, a delegate to the Constitutional Convention,  challenged the town of  Woburn to start a library after hearing about Boston’s plan for a public facility.  A free circulating library, housed in the town hall, did open to the public in 1856 but it wasn’t until the 1870s that Charles Winn (Jonathan’s son) left $140,000 for a dedicated building.  According to the library’s history, Charles wanted his generous gift to create a building that would be a “architectural ornament” for the town.  He certainly got his money’s worth when H.H. Richardson was declared the winner of the library design competition in 1877 (the same year that Richardson was hired to build the Ames Library).
Kenneth Breisch wrote a  whole book about Richardson’s libraries entitled Henry Hobson Richardson and the Small Public Library in America that offers a detailed account and analysis of each of the projects and their role in American society.  
The cool part about the Woburn story is that there was another library design competition held 129 years after Richardson won his contest.  The second competition was held in 2008 to generate ideas for an expansion project.  As massive as the Woburn Library appears, the space was not designed for 21st century technology nor does it offer the space for the library’s expanded collection and children’s room, it was time to grow .  The contest was for the best expansion idea (but not necessary the commission) that would work with Richardson’s design.   The winning design,  choosen from 100 entries, came from Lacina Heitler Architects, New York, NY (Design Team: Josh Heitler, Brian Cuff, Doug Houstoun, Marina Yu, Ed Rojas, Kevin Denlinger and Aaron Whitney).  
But here’s the kicker, Charles Winn isn’t around to finance the project and no one else seems to be jumping in to take his place.  According to Linda Kush, and the Gatehouse News Service, the Library Board and the City Council met last month and agreed to disagree on how much the city should (and can) contribute.  The Library Board is asking for $16.6 million and the Mayor is offerring $5.5 - that is quite a gap.  The actual cost of the addition is $24.4 million but $7.7 million will be covered by a grant from the Massachusetts Board of Library Commissioners and private donors.
Until they reach a compromise, Woburn Library patrons will have to live with overflowing shelves, a children’s room in the basement and the great beauty of H.H. Richardson’s design.