Showing posts with label architecture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label architecture. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

The Phantom and the Caterpillar

Milo and Tock from Norton Juster's Phantom Tollbooth
One of the reasons I love to run long distances is that it gives me more time to listen to NPR podcasts.  When else is there the time to listen to Neil Conan explain science, Tom Ashbrook debate about current events or Bob Edwards interview Norton Juster?
Norton Juster is a celebrity in my house.  His book, The Phantom Tollbooth is one of the cherished, not to be donated, paperbacks that we actually reread - it ranks in the book stratosphere with Harry Potter and To Kill A Mockingbird.  The book is a wonderful adventure story locked in a tangle of clever puns and riddles that make the reading fun on several levels.  Milo and his alarm clock dog, Tock, embark on a quest to rescue the princesses, Rhyme and Reason,  who are imprisoned in Digitopolis.  They don’t have to traverse the slough of despond but they do meet an endless cast of curious and challenging characters on their journey. As a teacher I found I could especially identify with their trek into the Mountains of Ignorance where they meet the Terrible Trivium who stalls them with busywork. :)
My running revelation during Bob Edward’s interview was that Norton Juster was never a full time author - he has only recently retired from his full time job as an architect.  Juster was a professor of design at Hampshire College for 22 years and founded a small architectural firm in Shelburne Falls, MA, Juster Pope Frazier Associates. His writing hobby resulted in ten published and includes the Hello, Goodbye Window with Chris Raschka that won a Caldecott Medal in 2006.  
If you are a children’s book junkie, like me, you may have perked up your ears when I mentioned Western Massachusetts because it is the home of the Eric Carle Picture Book Museum (and library).  The museum was founded by Eric Carle in 2002 and is peacefully planted in an apple orchard next to Hampshire College, near Holyoke, MA.  The mission of the museum is to foster an appreciation of  picture book art and it offers several galleries of rotating exhibits featuring the magical artwork of illustrators from beloved children’s books.   The museum library is an oasis of imagination - filled with 3,000 books, artwork, comfy seats and stuffed animals, Hannah and I promptly planted ourselves and started pulling old favorites off the shelves.  I think we spent more time reading books in the library and gift shop then we did in the gallery!
If you haven’t yet jumped to the Island of Conclusions (like Milo and Tock), then I’ll make the leap for you.  In 2002 Juster Pope Frazier Associates was hired to design and build Eric Carle’s Museum.  What perfect synergy!  The beautiful space is bright, open and airy and not a bit condescending.  Carle worked closely with the architects to create a blank slate space that could be filled with the color and vibrancy of the work within it.
One last connection...Jules Feiffer was the illustrator of Tollbooth back in 1961 and went on to have a successful career as an author and illustrator (Feiffer and Juster have actually recently collaborated again on a new book called the Odious Ogre).  This October Feiffer will be honored with his own exhibit at the museum and I imagine that Norton Juster will have a truly satisfying afternoon wandering through the galleries admiring the art and the architecture.  I can’t wait to go back myself.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Best Loved

Photo from Crane Library Website

In 2007 the American Institute of Architects and Harris Interactive embarked on a public poll to determine the 150 best loved building in America as a way to celebrate their 150th Anniversary.  It is absolutely no surprise the The Thomas Crane Memorial Library in Quincy, MA was number 43.  Trinity Church ranks 25 which gives H.H. Richardson two building in the top 50.  It’s particularly interesting to look at the other winners, they are mostly grandiose structures, built on a monumental scale (Sears Tower, Washington Monument, St. Patrick’s Cathedral), the Crane Library is tucked away between them like a little brother tagging along with the big kids.  The only other library higher on the list is The Library of Congress!  I can’t believe it took me so long to discover this gem.  The more I learn, the less I know.
When the poll was conducted, the AIA asked people to choose buildings that symbolized  innovation and the spirit of their community (or country).  But they also were looking for structures that held a special place in people’s hearts and minds.  That is what strikes me with all of Richardson’s libraries - they are warm and inviting yet also convey security and stability with their beauty.  They are crafted from gorgeous organic materials in a simple but decorative way - Richardson’s talent is overwhelming.  In Quincy he had a little help from Frederick Law Olmsted (Central Park) who designed the grounds and the artist John Lafarge who contributed three stained glass windows.
Richardson’s genius is the problem for those who come in his wake, especially for those who are charged with expanding his masterpiece.  CBT  (Childs Bertman Tseckares Inc.) designed a $16 million addition to the library that doubled the existing space, created a soaring atrium and added essential circulation and reference areas.  But even CBT architect Richard Bertman admits that “ you can’t buy the kind of ornamentation and sculpture that grace both the original H.H. Richardson library building or the 1939 addition known as the Coletti building.”  The library has actually expanded not once but four times in the last 120 years - and with good reason;  it has the second largest collection in Massachusetts after the Boston Public Library.  CBT also took care of renovating and restoring the existing buildings - get a towel because you will drool over the pictures of the interior.  The old and new Crane Library compliment each other (like the ultimate Reese’s PB Cup) to offer the residents of Quincy a spacious, remarkable haven for learning, sharing and thinking.  They are prepared to move into the future without forgetting the past.

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Inside Looking Out

I was so enthralled by Joshua Prince-Ramus’s explanation (and delivery) of the design process of the Seattle Public Library that I didn’t even have time to go inside for a tour yesterday.  But today is a new day and I have a new appreciation and understanding of modern library design.  My journey on this blog is to learn, think and grow each day, so mission accomplished.
In we go... the Seattle Public Library opened the doors on its eleven story masterpiece in May, 2004.  During the first year they hosted 8,000 visitors a day, I can’t even imagine 8,000 in my town let alone in the library, but it is a considerable space...doubling their numbers from the previous year.  There are several amateur tours of the library on youtube which give you the feeling of the atrium area that defines many of the floors.  It is particularly powerful upon entering the ‘Living Room’ on the 3rd level and gazing up fifty feet.  This space was designed with the knowledge that it was one of the few free public spaces available in the city and there is plenty of room for people to hang out, meet, eat, or just get warm.  
From the living room you can go down to the first level and into the children’s room - this space has its own entrance, computers, check-out and restrooms - obviously librarians and parents provide valuable insight to this design.  I can just picture my wild child loose in the living room and headed for the escalator - imagine how those little shrieks of joy would echo!  The children’s room offers story time in several languages and there is an extensive language lab and auditorium (it can seat up to 450 people).
Going back upstairs, the sixth through ninth floors of the library are an amazing continuous spiral of non-fiction books arranged in Dewey Decimal order, the numbers are painted right on the floor as you walk past each row of shelves (Melville would be proud).  The design allows the collection to grow without leading patrons on a wild goose chase between different areas of the library.  Ramus calls it a “parking garage for books”, a great way to visualize the space.  
My favorite space in most libraries is the reading room and Seattle’s is outstanding.  The Betty Jane Narver Reading Room is 12,000 square feet of skylit space on the 10th floor (with views of Elliott Bay) and has space for 400 readers!  Betty Jane Narver was a long time advocate of the Seattle  library and helped form the library foundation board in 1980.  Her death in 2001 prevented her from seeing this finished masterpiece but I can think of no greater memorial than this spectacular spot.
There is also a lovely gift shop, Friendshop, operated by ‘Friends of the Library’ and a coffee cart run by the Seattle based company Chocolati.  These are both small and don’t steal the focus from the important thing:  the books.
Phew - we are so lucky to have the Seattle Public Library to demonstrate what a library can be for a community, not only a place to read, learn and gather but also a monument to announce to the world who we are and we stand for...when I see this library I see Seattle as an authentic place, dedicated to supporting their community and committed to the advancement of the next generation.

Monday, January 31, 2011

Stunning in Seattle


Today is one of the most treasured of all days for teachers and students:  a snow day!  Actually,  its a ‘cold day’, with wind-chills at -19 degrees...brrrrr.  A perfect day to stay inside, sip hot coffee and visit the library.  I headed to Seattle (it is a toasty 46 degrees).
The story of the Seattle Public Library is one of growth, progress and the love of books.  This is a city that has its priorities straight and when it came time to come up with the cash to build their ‘temple’ they did it.  In 1998 the voters approved a $197 million bond issue (there was a 69% approval rating) - the largest ever for a library.  In addition to the bond (called ‘Libraries For All’) the library foundation raised $82 million from 22,000 donors, including $22.5 million from Paul Allen and $20 million from Bill & Melinda Gates.    
The architects, OMA in partnership with LMN Architects in Seattle, created a modern library masterpiece - winning the Pritzker Prize, Time Magazine’s building of the year (2004) and the hearts and minds of the world.  Joshua Prince-Ramus served as the partner in charge of the project and when I headed to his video at ted.com I was completely captivated by his intelligence, enthusiasm and thoughtfulness (you thought I was going to say his stunning good looks, but that was just a bonus).  I immediately decided to spend my ‘cold day’ morning with him...isn’t the Internet wonderful?
Ramus talks about the creative journey his firm and the library team embarked on during the creation of the library.  The journey resulted in two main ideas:  books and socializing.  At the heart of project is the word  BOOKS, which, he reminds us, are technology, and are now learning to share their dominance with other kinds of information technology.  The second idea, and he asserts that it is equally important, although at first the librarians were unconvinced, was to foster socialization.   
As background Ramus explains that the idea of ‘high modern’ design.  In a nutshell this idea asserts that spaces should have complete flexibility so they can be used for any activity - the starting point is the design and not the function of the space.  This leads to spaces that are generic and nondescript.  “Aha,” I said to my laptop, “ that is the feeling that I often get from modern libraries, although they are beautiful there is no personality or soul in the space.”  Ramus explains that in high modernism the reading room looks just like the copy room, the furniture is just different.  He goes on to explain that his firm took a compartmentalized approach and examined the specific uses of each space in the library.
The library team initially identified all the ways they wanted to use the library and then OMA created five functional boxes.  The boxes, each with their own specific function, are at the core of the design.  They are stacked, off kilter like a tower of presents and covered by a skin that provides structural stability and holds panes of treated glass (opaque from the outside and transparent from the inside).  In my simple mind, I see the library as five shoe boxes, stacked up and covered with plastic wrap and now it makes perfect sense and is delightful.  The library is not an abstract, modern marvel beyond my understanding...it is a series of spaces for people to meet, read, learn, and think, just like it always has been, this one, thanks to Ramus and his team, just happens to be stunning.

Saturday, January 22, 2011

Golden Oldie

So this is what I’m wondering...how does a city decide whether or not to restore an old library or build a new one?  Were some buildings built with better methods and materials  than others and therefore they last longer?  Is urban renewal at work?  Or maybe it is an operating and upkeep issue.  Once again I have far too many questions and not enough answers...

However, I was stunned when I stumbled across this picture of the old Buffalo Library (it was also located downtown at 1 Layfayette Square, the same address as the current library).  I had no idea that such a beautiful structure had existed on what is now a series of cement planter boxes and a windswept plaza.  This Gothic/Romanesque structure was designed by Cyrus Eidlitz (he also designed the famous New York Times Building, the namesake of Times Square, in 1905) and completed in 1887.  The cost was over $5 million dollars (roughly adjusted to current dollars).  The new modern library was built directly behind it in 1963 for the bargain price of $70 million dollars (adjusted to current dollars), the books were transferred to the new building and this treasure was levelled.  Seventy-six years...that’s it?  Doesn’t that  seem like the prime of life for such a substantial building?  The lions in front of the NYPL have been on guard since 1911 and they’re still going strong, The Redwood Library in Newport, RI is built around its original structure from 1750 and “The Old Library” at St. John’s College, part of the University of Cambridge, was built in the 1620s!  Even my house, which has had little TLC in the last 50 years,  is 130 years old and only falling apart in some places.
Heritage Press Magazine recounts author George Kunz’s memories of the library, “‘drafty, rambling, illogical’ but nonetheless having charm. It leaked, was hot in summer and cold in winter, and the wooden floors creaked.  When the Broadway streetcar rounded the bend on Washington Street, the huge windows in the reading room trembled and the floor shook until it passed.”  
Are these just the signs of an old building or inferior  construction?  As I search for answers I truly hope this beautiful building was not destroyed in order to provide quiet floors and geometric interiors.  While I know that Buffalo is famous for its urban renewal decisions, I find it hard to believe that they let this jewel go.
   
Muschamp, Herbert - "Landmarks are not created by architects. They are fashioned by those who encounter them after they are built. The essential feature of a landmark is not its design, but the place it holds in a city's memory. Compared to the place it occupies in social history, a landmark's artistic qualities are incidental."